Quick version: privacy-first VPN is a different category from streaming-first. The strongest picks trade some convenience (slower, no Netflix unblock optimization) for jurisdiction, audits, and anonymity.
The 3 picks
1. Mullvad - the privacy maximalist
Sweden, 16-digit account-only (no email, no name), accepts cash by mail, all open source, reproducible builds, audited annually. €5/mo flat. Trade-off: Netflix unreliable, no port forwarding, 5-device limit. Test your Mullvad →
2. ProtonVPN - balance of privacy + features
Switzerland, audited no-logs, open-source apps, full IPv6 tunneling (rare), Secure Core (double-VPN through privacy-friendly transit), genuinely safe free tier. Pricier than Mullvad on multi-year, but more streaming/feature-rich. Test your ProtonVPN →
3. PrivadoVPN - Swiss alternative
Switzerland, audited 2022, 10GB/mo free tier. Smaller and less battle-tested than ProtonVPN, but the same jurisdictional advantages. Test your PrivadoVPN →
Why we left some popular picks off this list
- NordVPN, Surfshark, ExpressVPN - all audited and competent, but Panama/BVI jurisdictions are slightly weaker than Switzerland on legal force, and not open source. Recommended for streaming/general use, not for privacy maximalism.
- HMA, IPVanish - past logging incidents under previous ownership. Currently audited, but legacy matters for some threat models.
- PIA - audited and verified-by-court no logs, but US jurisdiction (5 Eyes) is the trade-off. Pick on your threat model.
- Free VPNs - business model has to monetize somehow. ProtonVPN free is the exception (paid users subsidize free); most others sell data.
Practical privacy setup checklist
- Pick from Mullvad / ProtonVPN / PrivadoVPN based on jurisdiction preference
- Pay anonymously - cash by mail (Mullvad), Bitcoin (Proton, Mullvad), Monero (some)
- Use the VPN provider's own app (browser extensions are proxies, leakier)
- Enable kill switch in settings (always-on)
- Run our checker - confirm no WebRTC/IPv6 leaks before sensitive activity
- Use a privacy-respecting browser (Firefox + arkenfox config, or Brave) to reduce browser fingerprint matching
- Consider Tor over VPN for highest anonymity (slower, but unbreakable)
Bottom line: Mullvad for absolute maximalism, ProtonVPN for balanced privacy + features, PrivadoVPN as Swiss alternative. All three pass our leak checks; all three accept anonymous payment.